Anticiparory systems, Turbulence, Coevolution

Group 6 started their lecture with an experiment of complexity. Ten they talked about Robert Rosen, the biologist who corporate to the concept of anticipatory systems. He used all his efforts and employed different sciences such as mathematics and physics to answer the question, why we have the living systems and life? He believed that the casual basic of life is a matter of relational causality rather than physical-material causality. Rosen used the word “complexity “ for the organizational impact of influencing causality. He wrote his book “Anticipatory systems” on1985, trying to explain the reason for life. Then they defined the simple systems and complex systems. The simple system is a system that describes everything as finite set of formalisms. A simple system is sum of its parts and it is possible to be modeled. Simple systems have minimal organizational impact. In contrary, a complex system is not possible to be modeled or formalized in its all aspects. A complex system is more than sum of its part and it has potential from organizational impact.

Then they explained the anticipatory system as a natural system that contains an internal predictive model of itself and of its environment, which allows it to change state at an instant in accord with the model’s predictions, pertaining to a later instant. So an anticipatory system has timing, and it is functions based on encoding and decoding information of present time in order to predict the future situation. In physics time is considered as linear, but the anticipatory systems bring the future to present and change the meaning of physic’s time. Anticipatory systems allow organisms to make change before the changes are necessary and use their feedback systems to correct themselves.

The next title in the lecture was turbulence. Fredrick Emery and Eric Lansdown came up with the concept of “causal textures” that means that environment and the system has interaction and mutual influences on each other. They divided the environment to four different types that may have overlap. These types are:

  1. Random and placid; the resources are spread out randomly and you need to have tactics to get them.
  2. Random and clustered; the resources are clustered around the field and you need to have strategy to get them.
  3. Disturbed and reactive; similar systems or organizations are in competition
  4. Turbulent; the environment becomes highly uncertain and unpredictable and you need communication to get the resources.

Then they have a comparison between two network forms of negotiated order vs. legal order.

 

The next topic was coevolution. Coevolution is about emphasizing dimension of time. Learning is about the system responding to its environment. Coevolution is about whole-whole relations on living and non-living systems. In biology coevolution is when two species or more mutually affect each other’s evolution. This means that they can help each other by close ecological interaction.
What is coevolution in systems thinking? Two systems coevolve when they both evolve in the mentioned way and have meaningful influence in each other’s evolution. Coevolutionary connections can be mutually cooperative, competitive or dominative. Coevolution can be divided into direct and defused coevolution. Direct coevolution is about species to species. But many of the systems either in the natural and social world are in a non-direct coevolution such as institutions, technologies, believes, values and genes. Coevolution has been a key framework in understanding change in complex, socio-ecological systems, and as an important concept for the ecological economics. Ecological economics is an evolutionary science that aims to address the interconnection and coevolution of human economy and natural ecosystems over time and space.

 

Norgaard –considered as one of the founders of ecological economics- his research combines social economy and natural sciences. He suggests five types of coevolution:

  1. Biological coevolution: mutual evolution between two or more species- dealing with biodiversity
  2. Social coevolution: mutual evolution between two or more social systems: for example technology and institutions, population and industries, universities and organizations, organizations and their environment
  3. Gene-culture coevolution: interaction between cultural evolution and biological evolution of the human species, anthropology and biology
  4. Bio-social coevolution: between social evolution and non-human biological evolution
  5. Socio-ecological coevolution: how evolution in the social systems affect biophysical environment.

 

These open up interesting debate on ecological economics: How human nature and behavior can be shaped culturally? Whether biophysical environments limits crucially human societies or whether societies can overcome limits and adjust environment to their needs?

 

Refferences

  1. Rosen, Judith, and John Jay Kineman. 2005. Anticipatory systems and time: a new look at Rosennean complexity. Systems Research and Behavioral Science 22, no. 5: 399-412. doi:10.1002/sres.715.
  2. Paraphrasing Kallis G, Norgaard RB. Coevolutionary ecological economics. Ecological Economics. 2010 Feb 15;69(4):690.

 

 

 

Rich Picture

To be able to write my blog post of the third day, I needed to go back to the audios and presentations of group 4 and 5. Group 4 lecture’s started with the general systems’ theory and the hard and soft systems. However, as David commented during the lecture the definition of hard and soft systems that was presented, is mostly the ideas of the author of the article and not a general idea. The lecture was continued about dialogue, strategic dialogue and the generative dialogue. At the end group 4 planned to practice different dialogue types in a workshop. What was really interesting for me in this lecture was the idea of rich picture, because I found it very practical and directly related to my daily activates. Therefore, I am going to focus on rich pictures and their role in a problem solving process in this post.

 

Rich picture is a way to explore and define an entity of a problem through visualizing and diagraming it, in order to reach a cognitive model of the problem. Visualizing helps us to provide a shared understanding of the problem and gives us a big picture of the whole situation. A rich picture helps to open discussion and come to a shared understanding of the system. Creating a rich picture is the first step of the problem solving process. When you start solving a problem, which can be a design problem, the rich picture is in the center of your page. Drawing a rich picture is what I am used to do as an architect, facing new design subjects, but I was not using this name and I did not predicted that I will face the same method in a system thinking discourse. Learning about rich picture in system thinking context would help me to see the method from a different point of view and try to employ new things and involve them when I am drawing a rich picture for my next design problem.

 

Rich picture by iconic representations sums up the important elements of the problem situation and provides a mental image of it. The rich picture method was originally developed as part of Peter Checkland’s Soft Systems Methodology to describe the real world in two steps: first by identifying the issue you wish to address and second by developing an unstructured description of the situation where the issue lies1. Understanding of the situation’s certain elements such as structure; process, stakeholders and people, issues and conflict are included in the description of rich picture. The picture may uses diagrams, symbols, drawings, sketches and words. The picture should not follow a rigid structure (such as a process chain or flowchart), but reflects as much information of the issue and situation without privileging, predetermining or presuming a particular point of view, as Williams and Hummelbrunner point in their book ‘Systems Concepts in Action.2 To make a rich picture the situation that is needed to be evaluated should be drawn out on a large sheet of paper. The first elements in the picture are the physical entities involved in the situation. Ideally the rich picture is drawn in a group; if there is more than one group making rich picture for one project, the different pictures should be compared to discover the similar aspects and ideas and diverse ones.

 

Refferences

  1. Checkland P (2000) Research Paper. Soft Systems Methodology: A Thirty Year Retrospective, in Systems Research and Behavioral Science Syst.
  2. Bob Williams and Richard Hummelbrunner, 2010, Systems Concepts in Action: A Practitioner’s Toolkit, Sanford Califonia, Stanford University Press.

 

Boundary, Inquiry & Perspectives

To be able to write the diaries after almost 2 months from the class, I preferred to go back to the audios and listen to the lectures once again. Thanks David, this time new things were showed off to me. I summarized the lectures for my own, but I am not going to post the full summery here as my blog post. Just to point out the main topics, the group 2 focused on the concept of different perspective, boundaries and values. The lecture was started with a group activity with all students on the topic of Tallinn-Helsinki tunnel and was trying to reveal the role of individual’s perspective, experience, motivation and benefits in a discussion between different stakeholders. Ulrich’s Value Triangle shows how boundary judgment, observation and evaluation have interactive effect on each other. And he proposes the boundary criticism based on our experience: self-reflective boundary questioning, dialogical boundary questioning and controversial boundary questioning.

 

The next lecture topic was on different perspectives that could be seen- or ignored- in making a decision. This discussion takes us to the confrontation of citizens vs. professionals. Depends on to what extent democratic you want to make a decision, the process of decision-making could be limited to the professionals, or more open to the citizens and their different views and perspectives. This is the point that I want to focus on more in this text. In my field, architecture, for long time the common design process has been that the architect, as head of the design team, uses different expertise of the team members to make the final decision and design. These are all based on the project topic and its main concept, the needs and goals of the project and its possibilities and limitations of the projects as the facts. As different expertise involved in an architectural design project get more complex and professional, the architect prefers to involve his team members more into the decision making process (to be more accurate and avoid failure probabilities). This is already happened in the design teams for several decades more or less in many design teams. Later on, to have a more successful design, many architecture offices tried to get closer to future users of the building and get their needs and opinions beforehand to use in the design process. In the recent years, I have got to know a new method or attitude, which goes a pace further and more directly involves people, as the social stakeholders of the building, along with the other stakeholders into and during the design process and the decision making. This method is called participatory design and “is an approach to the assessment, design, and development of technological and organizational systems. The impetus of Participatory Design is to encourage the active involvement of potential or current end-users of a system in the design and decision-making processes.” 2 This method is- in my opinion- in the trial and error step in discipline of architecture, and is getting more popular in academic approach of architectural design, specially in socialist countries such as Finland.

 

In the following the lecture was about the boundary issues and divided them to four main categorize of: 1. Sources of motivation, 2. Sources of power, 3. Sources of knowledge, 4. Sources of legitimation. The three first categorize are those who involved in the decision-making and the forth group is those who affected by it. What was discussed, as a conclusion is that in order to make the best possible judgment and decision in the end, different stakeholders should understand others’ boundaries, and make the gap between the involved and affected groups as less as possible; for instance experts and citizens should question each other to reach an acceptable extent of mutual understanding.

 

References

  1. Ulrich, W (2000) Reflective practice in the civil society
  2. Stanford University, http://cs.stanford.edu

Appreciative Systems

Geoffrey Vickers (1894-1982) is the initiator of the idea of “appreciative systems”. Generally Vickers’ work in systems thinking was focused on nature of human systems and decision-making. His main contributions to system thinking are:

  1. Emphasizing the key importance of human relationships as a way of understanding systems. Vickers believed that maintaining human relationships is the heart of all human activities, especially in organizations. His idea was in contrast with the traditional models of management that were focused on goal seeking.
  1.    He argued that systems should be thought of as tools of understanding rather than a precise description of reality. “It is only once we have a sense of the system as a device for understanding rather than a statement about the nature of the world, that it becomes possible to look at systems from multiple perspectives and to respect all of those perspectives as equally valid”. (System thinkers, 2009 by Springer London, Chapter 8, p 79.)
  1.    Vickers’ third and most significant contribution was the concept of the “appreciative system”, a description of the ongoing process of sense-making over time. He used the term appreciation to refer to a combined judgment of value and fact.

 

APPRECIATIVE SYSTEMS

Vickers argued that any decision contains these three judgments. Therefore any attempt to improve decision-making needs to improve the quality of one or more of these judgments. Appreciative judgment is included of three components:

  1. Reality Judgment

Reality judgment is based on sense making of the situation, which is based on an understanding of the state of the system. It is based on surfacing, sharing and challenging, structuring and restructuring the perceptions as well as negotiation and agreement of meaning, and alignment or accommodation of diverse views.

Reality judgment should answer to the question “What is or is not the case?” It is about the facts; ranging from basic cause-and-effect beliefs to more subtle and complex ones; Fact about the “state of the system”, both internally and in its external relations. Reality judgment should answer what the state of the system has been and what the state will be or might be on various hypotheses (cover past, present or future of the system).

  1. Value Judgment

Value judgment is what gives meaning to reality judgments. Value judgment should be able to answer the question “What ought or ought not be the case?” It shows the significance of the facts.

“The relation between judgments of fact and of value is close and mutual; for facts are relevant only in relation to some judgment of value, and judgments of value are operative only in relation to some configuration of fact”.

  1. Instrumental Judgment

Instrumental judgment is about strategic choice and aims to reduce the mismatch between “is and ought”. It determines the appropriate responses to reality & value judgments and if something could be done about a situation assessed as unsatisfactory by value judgment, and if so, what?

Instrumental judgment is about reacting to negative result of value judgment and the best move that we get to resolve the situation, using available resources including the personal resources of time, attention, intellect, passion, money, and power or social resources that can be applied through communication, coalition, and access to social institutions.

 

The text above is mainly collected from the articles that I read on appreciative systems plus small modifications of mine. The appreciative system theory as I understood is an explanation of what actually happens when we are trying to make a decision. In simple words we try to understand what is happening, and recognize the desirable and undesirable parts of it, then we value them and decide on actions about the undesirable parts based on our available resources of money, time, power, etc. More or less this theory is always applied on human’s process of rational decision-making. Being aware of what really happens during the process, we will have the chance to review and analyze each part of it, and is helping to improve our decision-making process.

While almost each decision-making process is using the steps of the appreciative judgment, in many cases the theory is not much focus of interest or appreciated, especially by individuals and in daily events. But there are parties to be interested on it. There are professionals that are using these methods to help organizations to improve their systems. These professionals could be insiders or outsiders of the organization; in both cases they practically use the systems theory. In addition there are professions studying human’s minds structure, the ways he thinks, decides and acts. I think they are mutual stakeholders of system thinking theories, since the study case of both disciplines overlaps a lot.

Having the knowledge of theory makes the individual aware and conscious about what s/he is really doing during the decision-making process. Depends on the person and her/his thinking methods, s/he can get advantage of this awareness. The decision-making process could be improved by focusing and analyzing each step of the judgments, or could be checked by a process of reciprocate feedback. I think this knowledge is applicable in every day’s life decisions as well as the special occasions that we may use it in our career- organizational decisions. As an architect I think the process of judgment is useful for me in the design process. As in the design process we use pretty similar process of getting the information of background and current situation of the case and its site, valuing the situation and then try to design based on the judgment we have. Therefore I think this process is quite practical for designers of built environment include of architects.